Main

PTQ Berlin 2008 Archives

May 23, 2008

First PTQ Berlin, 2008 - overview

SSO and I took part in the first PTQ of the season for Berlin 2008, at Pro Tour Hollywood 2008. You can read the PT Hollywood coverage here. One of the curious features of actually being at the event is that we have no real idea what's going on in the Pro Tour proper. We've been popping our heads out every so often to see what's going on, but that's not a clear picture. After I write up this quick overview of the first PTQ, I'm going to check out the YouTube coverage, and then SSO and I will be doing some deck building for tomorrow's PTQ.

The high-level view of today's PTQ? Well, there were some Faeries decks, but not as many as I'd expected. There's also a Doran aggro/tempo deck that operates much as the Extended Doran did, with Bitterblossom playing the role of Dark Confidant (i.e. "I trade life for stuff advantage"). There's also a terribly annoying five-color Elementals deck that tries to get lots of value out of Elementals evoked, in play, and in the graveyard.

Anyway, here's the high-level view of my eight match opponents in today's PTQ:

Round 1: BRG Planeswalkers and removal, featuring Spitebellows, Chandra Nalaar, Garruk Wildspeaker, and Nameless Inversion

Round 2: Mono-green Elf token horde (Gilt-Leaf Ambush, Promenade, Perfects...)

Round 3: Five-color Elementals

Round 4: WBG Treefolk with Doran

Round 5: UB Faeries (with Broken Ambitions playing the role of Rune Snag)

Round 6: WR Giants

Round 7: Five-color Elementals

Round 8: WBG Doran with Bitterblossom

There were a lot more Vivid Lands than I'd expected, but I'm definitely biased against them. Certainly, many mana bases were very colorful, but the format seems slow enough for that to work out okay.

Okay. Time to go redesign for tomorrow. Today's PTQ began at noon. Tomorrow, we start at 10am.

May 27, 2008

Summer Magic events - Regionals, PTQs

Having just competed in the first two PTQs of the Pro Tour Berlin 2008 PTQ season, I took a look today at upcoming tournaments on the summer schedule. As it happens, Regionals is right around the corner, and the PTQs in our area come late in the season. Let's take them in order...

U.S. Regionals take place very, very soon, on Saturday, June 7. The format is Standard. You can find information on Regionals and see where your Regionals is at the information page here. The Bay Area regionals will once again have four invites to Nationals.

Following the two PTQs we attended at Hollywood, the Berlin PTQ season is going to go into full swing starting in mid-June. You can find your local PTQs by going to your region from the PTQ info page. Our area qualifiers are:

June 28, at the San Jose Convention Center - This will be Lorwyn-Morningtide-Shadowmoor
August 16, at the Santa Clara Convention Center - This will be Lorwyn-Morningtide-Shadowmoor-Eventide
August 23, at Great Escape Games in Sacramento - This will be Lorwyn-Morningtide-Shadowmoor-Eventide

The Los Angeles PTQs (two of them) are both TBA.

Note that Eventide becomes legal on July 25.

May 28, 2008

PTQ Berlin #2 at PT Hollywood 2008

After my eight-round dry run at the first PTQ for Berlin, 2008, I retooled my deck and hit the second PTQ on Saturday. This was a huge PTQ, even by oversized NorCal standards, with 274 players (that's nine rounds). I went 3-2 drop, being unwilling to burn another 4 rounds in hope of prizes or competitive intelligence for later in the PTQ season. In the extended, I'll give an overview of my deck, and the matchups. I ran a Planeswalker control build heavily influenced by Stuart Wright's Worlds deck in 2007, and my general-purpose affection for Ms. Vess.

Manamorphose.jpgLilianaVess.jpgFirespout.jpg

Continue reading "PTQ Berlin #2 at PT Hollywood 2008" »

June 10, 2008

The top eights from Hollywood -- PTQ season starters

Although Wizards is lagging a bit on this count (as far as I can tell), Star City Games has the top eights from both PTQs that took place at PT Hollywood. I've already talked a bit about what I played against in the first PTQ, and gave a more detailed accounting of my performance in the second PTQ. I didn't stick around for either top eight, so although I heard a bit about each one the day after, this is the first chance I've had to actually look at the decks.

Click here for the first top eight
Click here for the second top eight

PTQ Berlin: Urchin Blossom

DuskUrchins.jpgBitterblossom.jpgCorrupt.jpg

Looking through the top eights of the first two PTQs for Berlin 2008, we see mainly familiar archetypes, including a flood of faeries -- four in the first one, five in the second. One interesting choice from the second PTQ is Nicolas Rolf's mono-black control build, which uses many of the best black cards, and attempts to leverage the Tendrils-like power of Corrupt into success. More in the extended entry.

Continue reading "PTQ Berlin: Urchin Blossom" »

June 12, 2008

Creatureless cycle control in Lorwyn

Cycles.jpg

I think I proposed this or something like it as a joke to SSO when we were attending PT Hollywood. Basically, "throw one of each cycle in" and go from there. In practice, I went for the restrained form of that approach, as I've only thrown in three cycles -- the planeswalkers, the commands, and the hybrid lands.

This tests surprisingly well against Kithkin and Faeries. No, that's not a recommendation to play it at a PTQ.

It does create hilarious game states, though.

Full list in the extended.

Continue reading "Creatureless cycle control in Lorwyn" »

June 19, 2008

PTQ Berlin 2008 - The first wave of faeries and hobbits

Wizards has posted the first set of decklists from the 2008 Berlin PTQ season. Click here for the decklist page, and click here for Mike Flores' analysis of the results to date. So far, Faeries and Kithkin are the most abundant among top eight participants, but wins have gone to Merfolk, Faeries, and a five-color control deck (note that Mike doesn't yet cover all the wins listed in the results).

The full top eight lists reveal some interesting deck choices that Flores didn't touch on, included in the extended entry.

Continue reading "PTQ Berlin 2008 - The first wave of faeries and hobbits" »

June 26, 2008

This week in PTQing for Berlin

Three more PTQ top eights appeared this week, although apparently after Mike Flores' most recent Swimming with Sharks column. He covers "one and a half" of them in his column, but there was some interesting material in the remaining builds that he didn't have a chance to address.

As always, you can read the collected decklists here.

The most notable trend from the top eights is the lack of Kithkin, and the concomitant lack of maindeck countermeasures against Kithkin. In this most recent batch of PTQs, we see people preferentially putting their mass removal into the sideboard. This feels like a hopeful thing to me, as I find that having to account for a lot of Kithkin opposition really skews my prospective decklists. That said, this is exactly the kind of metagame thing that can swing back and forth week to week -- after all, if too many people decide not to bother really stopping Kithkin, it suddenly becomes a tremendously good deck. Again.

In the extended, I take a look at three decks that caught my eye. We have Utility Horde, featuring a collection of useful creatures riding on a wave of Faerie Rogues from the Blossom, Primal Elementals featuring a ton of elementals and four Primal Commands in the maindeck, and Elf Party, an Elf deck that features many non-Elf party guests.

Continue reading "This week in PTQing for Berlin" »

July 05, 2008

PTQ Berlin 2008: Liliana kills Faeries

Thoughtseize.jpgLilianaVess.jpgGarrukWildspeaker.jpg

But sadly, not much else.

I brought the latest version of my black/green Planeswalker Control build to the PTQ this morning in San Jose. I dropped after my third loss (the second loss puts you cleanly out of qualifying range in a 188-person PTQ, and the third puts you out of prize range and, in my case, shows that your brain is no longer in the game).

Full report in the extended.

Continue reading "PTQ Berlin 2008: Liliana kills Faeries" »

Um, judge?

In general, you shouldn't be shy about calling a judge at a tournament. It's not automatically a commentary on your opponent -- you can always just say, "I'm just not sure about this situation, so I'd like to ask."

In round one of today's PTQ, in the game immediately next to me, everything ground to a complete halt when the guy seated beside me played a Wrath of God.

Pause. Silence.

"That's not legal in this tournament."

"It's not?"

"Um, judge?"

When the deck was checked, the guy had twelve Tenth Edition cards in his deck, including four Wraths, four Llanowar Elves, and some other kind of removal. He'd thought that Tenth Edition was also legal in block.

Faced with the option of replacing twelve cards in his deck with basic lands, he chose to drop from the tournament.

That's certainly the most interesting judge call I've ever been near.

July 12, 2008

PTQ Berlin 2008: Staid Ukrainians, inventive Belgians, and Greek Transformers

Giant leading edit: I apologize for my geography flub. Odessa is in the Ukraine. I just noticed that I gifted it to Russia. I'm definitely too much of a child of the cold war.

As we head into the middle span of the PTQ season for Berlin 2008, forums ring with complaints that the combined Lorwyn - Morningtide - Shadowmoor qualifier format is utterly stale. Of the 32 top-eight decks reported from the latest PTQ (as always, not including any Northern California PTQs as they consistently don't make it into Wizards' hands), just shy of half (15) were Faeries. More to the point, perhaps, three of the four blue envelopes went to Faeries.

As always, you can check these results yourself here.

Over on Star City Games, I noticed top eights from three recent European PTQs, held in Odessa, Antwerp, and Thessalonika. I took a quick look through the lists to see what jumped out at me.

The Ukrainian top eight was the most conventional, with the top four (and the eighth) places going to Faeries. Of the remaining three slots, two went to Kithkin, and one to Elementals. All the builds cleaved close to the known designs.

The Belgian top eight was oddly Hobbit-heavy, with three Kithkin decks making the cut and only two Faeries. The remaining slots went to a Doran deck with a guest appearance from Brion Stoutarm, the winning Merfolk deck, and "Swan Command."

Say what?

Sung Kocks' Swan Command build (click here to see it) is a basic five-color control frame with the addition of three Swans of Bryn Argoll, triple Tarfire, a full quartet of Firespouts and double Incendiary Command. Let's take a moment here to remember how Swans was going to be an incredible and dominating combo card. Ah, well. In this build, I imagine the Swans are there to turn your Incendiaries and board-sweeping Firespouts into card-drawing opportunities -- until someone Inversions them. The Swans version of five-color control was good enough to power Sung into seventh place, which isn't bad in Antwerp.

The other deck of note from the Antwerp PTQ is the Faeries deck piloted by Mark Dictus (click here to see it). Following in the footsteps of fellow Belgian Marijn Lybaert, Mark ran a Faeries deck with eight Vivid Lands and four Firespouts. Main. With three Kithkin decks making it through to the top eight, that seems like a metagame call for the area, and perhaps one that paid off. Mark's build loses strength against the mirror to pack in those Spouts, as it has neither Peppersmokes nor Thoughtseizes, but it is otherwise not particularly hampered -- and maybe the Antwerp metagame took out many of the other Faeries decks.

The Greeks ran the farthest afield, although I almost missed one of their two weird decks. As listed on Star City, the Thessalonika top eight consisted of double Kithkin, double Faeries, double Elementals, Ten Commandments, and a deck labeled "Optimus Prime."

We'll take that one second.

First off, let's take a closer look at Kostantinos Karafotis's woefully mislabeled "Ten Commandments." It's a given that a stock Commandments (now just as likely to be thought of as block Quick 'n' Toast, or five-color control, or whatever) doesn't run ten actual Commands. One might have chosen to rename this deck, however, when it fell to just four commands. Two Primal, two Austere. That's it. Take a moment to click here and read the decklist.

This deck runs a host of chunky creatures, with triple Grim Poppet, a singleton Arbiter of Knollridge, quadruple Thresher, and quadruple Oversoul of Dusk. Man. That's all accelerated out with Druids and Fertile Grounds, and backed up by triple Garruk and the ubiquitous playset of Firespouts. Its mana base is also shockingly clean for all that it's trying to do, with twelve Basic Lands, six hybrid duals, four Reflecting Pools, and no Vivids.

Fascinating, and good enough for sixth place.

The cutely named "Optimus Prime," run by Petros Apotsos, is a sort of "boot to the head with big stuff" build (click here to see it). Perhaps thinking of it as a way around the highly reactive Faeries decks, Petros runs a full set of Dramatic Entrance. The Entrance lets him play out all his creatures as Instants, and provides a one-mana discount of the Threshers and a whopping three-mana discount on the Woodfall Primus.

And see, now you know where the deck gets its name.

On top of this, he has triple Primal Command (also playing into the name), triple Incendiary, and quadruple Firespout. He has quadruple Garruk as well. Like Karafotis, Apotsos loves the Oversoul, although he keeps his in the sideboard. And again, the mana base is entirely clear of Vivids, although he does run comes-into-play-tapped lands in the form of four Mosswort Bridges.

And he wins. Petros and his wacky R/G build took first place. How cool is that?

July 13, 2008

Post-Eventide Planeswalkers

BloomTender.jpgLilianaVess.jpgHallowedBurial.jpg

Heading toward the post-Eventide PTQ Berlin season, we see a lot of options opening up for non-Faerie builds. Faeries, it seems, will stay basically the same (caveat: I may have missed something utterly gamebreaking in my review of the cards so far). Although I've toyed with a number of ideas, ranging from random Rock builds using the new B/G cards through a weird attempt at a block Goblin Bidding deck using Pyrrhic Revival (hint: this probably doesn't work), my affections remain with Planeswalkers.

Fortunately for me, I've picked up a solid tool that this kind of deck really needs to work. A Wrath.

Check out the extended for a provisional decklist.

Continue reading "Post-Eventide Planeswalkers" »

July 28, 2008

One more time, Bay Area (Pro Tour Qualifier for Berlin 2008)

The last Bay Area PTQ for Berlin is coming next month. Per the qualifier schedule page, it's happening on August 16th, at the Santa Clara Convention Center.

Between the two typical Bay Area PTQ venues, I tend to prefer the Santa Clara Convention Center to the San Jose Convention Center. Both lack character, but Santa Clara is cleaner and has much better parking.

More on possible PTQ decklists later -- we'll have six post-Eventide PTQs before that PTQ weekend (one of them was two days ago in Springfield, a mere day after the Eventide release -- that's a seriously untested format!).

July 29, 2008

PTQ Berlin 2008: A smidgen of new tech

Coming nigh on one day after the release of Eventide, the Springfield, MO PTQ is probably wholly nonrepresentative of what full block play will look like for the remaining PTQs of this season. Even so, some Eventide cards did creep into the top eight. Let's go deck by deck in the extended.

Continue reading "PTQ Berlin 2008: A smidgen of new tech" »

August 03, 2008

Knowledge from Kobe

Grand Prix Kobe 2008 has ended, and may (or may not) have something to say about deck choices for the remainder of the Lorwyn-Shadowmoor block constructed PTQ season.

More notes in the extended.

Continue reading "Knowledge from Kobe" »

August 07, 2008

PTQ Berlin 2008 - On the (statistical) significance of Faeries

One of the things I enjoy doing during each constructed Pro Tour Qualifier season is reading through the posted decklists, looking for interesting novel choices or just overall trends in successful builds. There are a number of resources for decklists from the current Berlin 2008 Pro Tour Qualifier season:

2008 PTQ Berlin decklists at Wizards
Star City Games deck database
Deckcheck.net

These are partially but not entirely overlapping resources, so it's good to check in with all of them to get a comprehensive view.

One thing I felt I'd been noticing during the current Lorwyn-Shadowmoor block constructed PTQ season was a tendency for Faeries decks to appear more often in the top eights of larger tournaments. But was that just my personal impression, or is there something to it?

Click through to the extended article for the answer.

Continue reading "PTQ Berlin 2008 - On the (statistical) significance of Faeries" »

A thousand blooms - infinite mana in Lorwyn block

Scuttlemutt.jpgBloomTender.jpgSeedcradleWitch.jpg

Everyone is already familiar at this point with the arbitarily-large-critter combo of Devoted Druid with Quillspike. Even before the full set spoiler came out, I suggested a Project-X-inspired Quillspike build here. Now, an arbitrarily large creature is a lot of fun, but can we set our sights even higher and shoot for an arbitrarily large amount of mana?

Yes. Read the extended for the somewhat-misleadingly named Thousand Bloom combo, all packaged and ready to go.

Continue reading "A thousand blooms - infinite mana in Lorwyn block" »

August 08, 2008

Bloom King - infinite mana, redux

My initial take on using the Bloom Tender engine to generate infinite mana was the light-hearted and not-so-durable Thousand Blooms. Since then, I've been pondering how you'd actually wrap this engine into a durable frame - something more on the line of Project X.

More in the extended.

Continue reading "Bloom King - infinite mana, redux" »

August 10, 2008

Aachen is pessimal, Montreal is red

Two interesting sets of results from Berlin Pro Tour Qualifier top eights came in this week. First, we have the top eight from a 58-person PTQ in Aachen:

1. Faeries
2. Faeries
3. Faeries
4. Faeries
5. Faeries
6. Kithkin
7. Kithkin
8. Kithkin

So what were the two best decks in the format again?

However, a second set of results from a 110-person PTQ in Montreal says that we aren't stuck in a mire of Faeries and Hobbits:

1. UG Merfolk (including that chunkiest of Merfolk, the Chameleon Colossus)
2. Red
3. Faeries
4. Red
5. Kithkin
6. Red
7. Edge of the Divinity (that is, black/white)
8. Red

Click through on either link for full deck lists.

August 16, 2008

Tournament report -- Romper Room at PTQ Berlin 2008

I just returned early from the final PTQ I'll be attending for the 2008 Berlin PTQ season. I brought my latest iteration of a Planeswalker-centric control deck. Overall, I think it performed as well as it could have, but I should have made some different design decisions and a few different play decisions as well. Click through to the extended for the decklist, some explanations about that decklist, five rounds of tournament report, and then a revised decklist that I'd use if I went again.

Continue reading "Tournament report -- Romper Room at PTQ Berlin 2008" »

August 18, 2008

And the winner was...

Deck lists from Bay Area Magic events typically don't make it on the Wizards site proper. My understanding is that's down to whether or not the TO forwards them the lists. That said, the top eight decks from our recent PTQ for Berlin 2008 have appeared here at DeckCheck.net. It was Faeries taking the envelope as the sole representative of that archetype, with the rest of the top eight a decent mix of Kithkin, blue-white Retrace action, Doran, five-color control, and Merfolk. Notably, no red decks, despite their prevalence on the day.

My report from that event is here.

September 06, 2008

Last call in Rimini, and a goal for next season

The last major event in the Lorwyn-Shadowmoor block constructed season is coming up next weekend with Grand Prix Rimini 2008.

Rimini is on Italy's eastern coast, southeast of Bologna and east of Firenze. I was in Firenze earlier this year -- quite nice. Good churches, good food. If I were magically transported to the GP next week I'd bring my final worked Romper Room variant, as described at the end of this post.

Following Rimini, we step into the qualifier season for Kyoto, which will be Alara sealed (the full PTQ season for 2009 can be found here). This brings me to my goal for the coming PTQ season:

Figure it out sooner.

This was my second full PTQ season where I attended the majority of events I could reach, and the first where I've really had full access to the cards I'd need. One thing I realized, going along through this season, is that it took me a while to realize what was fundamentally important for succeeding in the format. Obviously, PTQ seasons are scheduled such that the metagame is a moving target as you go along (with new sets coming into the format), but that only adds pressure to be able to quickly figure out what's going to matter for allowing a win.

In my case, I realized soon after starting the last PTQ of the Lorwyn-Shadowmoor season that I really should have just bit the bullet, accepted that Vivids were a good idea, and had four Firespouts in addition to my Hallowed Burials. Basically, I need to be less in love with a concept (in this case "not having lands come into play tapped") and more willing to be flexible in what I push into my final build.

How will this apply for Alara sealed? Well, I recall from my single outing for the Kuala Lumpur PTQ season that I decided to go two colors, despite seeing triple Avian Changeling in the deck and thinking "It would be good to have flyers..." In the upcoming Alara season, I think it'll be similar -- trying to teach myself to make the best choices, considering not just what's in my pool but also what one can expect to see in everyone else's pools.

I'm looking forward to all the upcoming qualifiers for the 2009 season. Alara Sealed, then Extended, then Standard, along with Standard Regionals. That's a lot of fun queued up for 2009.

About the author

Alexander Shearer is a biologist, gamer, and writer. He has written for games and educational comics, and writes the ongoing In Development column at ChannelFireball.com when he's not collecting his gaming thoughts here at Gifts Ungiven.

About PTQ Berlin 2008

This page contains an archive of all entries posted to Gifts Ungiven in the PTQ Berlin 2008 category. They are listed from oldest to newest.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.